Home • About Us • A-Z Index • Search * Contact Us • Register • Login • Press • Shop

The Open Brand -- Problem Reporting and Interpretations System

Problem Report 2236 Details

Help Show help | Quick Search | Submit a Test Suite Support Request | Click here to view your privileges

This page provides all information on Problem Report 2236.

Report 2236 Actions

    Problem Report Number 2236
    Submitter's Classification Specification problem
    State Resolved
    Resolution Permanent Interpretation (PIN)
    Problem Resolution ID PIN.X.0254
    Raised 1970-01-01 08:00
    Updated 2003-03-13 08:00
    Published null
    Product Standard CORBA
    Certification Program The Open Brand certification program
    Test Suite VSORB version 1.1.1
    Test Identification API/pObjects/Vscreate_recursive_sequence_tc1 VScreate_recursive_sequence_tc1
    Specification CORBA 2.1
    Location in Spec See Problem Text
    Problem Summary PIN4O.00002 There is no clear specification on how to implement this, and it's deprecated in the next release
    Problem Text
    There is no clear specification on how to implement this, and it's
    deprecated in the next release

    Test Output
    300|275 /tset/c++/api/pObjects/ORB/VScreate_sequence_tc1 10:52:19|Clean Start, scenario ref 93-0
    320|275 0 10:52:20|Clean End, scenario ref 93-0
    110|276 /tset/c++/api/pObjects/ORB/VScreate_recursive_sequence_tc1 10:52:20|Build Start, scenario ref 94-0
    130|276 0 10:53:23|Build End, scenario ref 94-0
    10|277 /tset/c++/api/pObjects/ORB/VScreate_recursive_sequence_tc1 10:53:23|TC Start, scenario ref 94-0
    100|277|/build/i5/bin:/build/i5/tools/common/bin:/build/i5/lib:/build/i5/lib/en_US:/build/i5/tools/aix/bin:/build/i5/tools/rios_aix_4/bin:/build/i5/tools/aix/java/bin:/build/i0131.05/bin:/build/i0131.05/lib/en_US:/build/i0131.05/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/bin:/build/i0131.05/tools/common/bin:/build/i0131.05/tools/rios_aix_4/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/ioc.t/bin:/build/i0131.05/tools/rios_aix_4/bin:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/ioc.t/bin::/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/j
    ava/jre/bin:
    100|277|/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/java/bin:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/java/jre/bin/classic:/usr/bin:/usr/ucb:/etc:/usr/sbin:/sbin:/usr/vacpp/bin:/home/tet/adl-1.2beta5/bin:/home/tet/vsOrb/bin:/build/bin:/home/tet/bin:/home/tet:.:/home/cbuser/sqllib/bin:/home/cbuser/sqllib/adm:/home/cbuser/sqllib/misc:.
    100|277|.:/build/i5/src/shasta:/build/i5/tools/ASV/orb/lib/ibmjbde.zip:/build/i5/tools/ASV/client/lib/ujc.jar:/build/i5/lib/somshcl.zip:/build/i5/lib/somshor.zip:/build/i5/lib/somaxic.zip:/build/i5/tools/aix/java/lib/classes.zip:.:/build/i0131.05/src/shasta:/build/i0131.05/export/classes/jbinding:/build/i0131.05/lib/somshcl.zip:/build/i0131.05/lib/somshor.zip:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/common/lib/ujc.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/common/lib/ras.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/common/lib/websphere.j
    ar:/build/i0
    100|277|131.05/tools/ASV/common/lib/ejbcontainer.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/common/lib/csicpi.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/common/lib/ns.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/server/common/lib/runtime.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/common/lib/eex.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/server/common/lib/ace.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/common/lib/j2ee.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/common/lib/utils.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/common/lib/nls.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/common/lib/xml4j.jar:/build/i0131.05/t
    ools/ASV/adm
    100|277|in/adv/common/l
    100|277|ib/admin.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/admin/adv/common/lib/console.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/iwsorb.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/ASV/iwstools.jar:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/java/lib/tools.jar:/usr/java_dev2/lib/classes.zip:.:/home/cbuser/sqllib/java/sqlj.zip:/home/cbuser/sqllib/java/db2java.zip:/home/cbuser/sqllib/java/runtime.zip:.
    100|277|/build/i5/bin:/build/i5/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/rios_aix_4/bin:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/ioc.t/bin:/build/i0131.05/tools/rios_aix_4/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/lib:/build/i0131.05/lib:/build/i0131.05/lib/en_US:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/java/jre/bin:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/java/jre/bin/classic:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/dce/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/db2/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/ioc.t/lib
    100|277|/build/i5/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/ioc.t/lib:/build/i0131.05/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/ioc.t/lib:/build/bin:/home/cbuser/sqllib/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/db2/lib:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/java/jre/bin:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/java/jre/bin:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/java/bin:/build/i0131.05/tools/aix/java/jre/bin/classic:/build/i0131.05/tools/rios_aix_4/bin
    100|277|SOMCBASE=/build/i5
    100|277|SOMCBPROPS=/build/i5/props
    100|277|SOMCBENV=properties:/build/i5/props
    100|277|Calling ORB_init()
    100|277|ORB_init() passed
    100|277|Calling BOA_init()
    100|277|BOA_init() passed
    80|277 1536 10:53:26|TC End, scenario ref 94-0
    300|278 /tset/c++/api/pObjects/ORB/VScreate_recursive_sequence_tc1 10:53:26|Clean Start, scenario ref 94-0
    320|278 0 10:53:27|Clean End, scenario ref 94-0

    Review Information

    Review Type TSMA Review
    Start Date null
    Completed null
    Status Complete
    Review Recommendation No Resolution Given
    Review Response
    There's no indication that the feature is mandatory in the CORBA 2.1
    profile and the fact that it's deprecated in CORBA 2.3 shows that




    its usage and its implementation are not clear. We therefore think
    the customer has a case here and should have the request granted. As a
    consequence of that, the test case should be removed from the test suite
    as well as from the CORBA 2.1 conformance questionnaire.


    Review Type SA Review
    Start Date null
    Completed null
    Status Complete
    Review Resolution Permanent Interpretation (PIN)
    Review Conclusion
    A Permanent Interpretation is granted.

    Problem Reporting System Options:

     

    Back   

Contact the Certification Authority