Home • About Us • A-Z Index • Search * Contact Us • Register • Login • Press • Shop

The Open Brand -- Problem Reporting and Interpretations System

Problem Report 2191 Details

Show help | Quick Search | Submit a Test Suite Support Request | Click here to view your privileges
This page provides all information on Problem Report 2191.

Report 2191 Actions

Problem Report Number 2191

Submitter's Classification Minor System Fault

State Resolved

Resolution Test Suite Deficiency (TSD)

Problem Resolution ID TSD.X.1110

Raised 1970-01-01 08:00

Updated 2003-03-13 08:00

Published 1998-08-18 08:00

Product Standard Motif Toolkit

Certification Program The Open Brand certification program

Test Suite VSM version 4.0.0

Test Identification vsm4/tset/widgets/XmSelectionDialog4 test4A

Problem Summary TSD4M.00016 This report is asking for such kind of error: INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=2 ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemCount: Expected 3, received 8 or INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=1 ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemC...

Problem Text
This report is asking for such kind of error:

INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=2
ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemCount: Expected 3, received 8

or

INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=1
ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemCount: Expected 3, received 11

This is caused by the system design problem. Refer to report.zw030
for related information and TSD4M.00013 for waiver.
The test case is in ../vsm4/tset/selectiond.c/test4A.
The stack sequence to reach where the errors happen is:

(*testWidgetClassInfo->proc_TestBehavior) (testWidgetClassInfo,
parentWidgetInfo);
/**** ../vsm4/tset/selectiond.c/test4A. *******/

static void TestBehavior(widget_class_info, parent_info)
MvsWidgetClassInfo *widget_class_info;
MvsWidgetInfoRecord *parent_info;
{
for( i = start ; i < end ; i++ ) {
...........................................................
mvsBoxBehaviorSet(widget_class_info,parent_info,focus_mode,
args,nargs, i+1);

} /* End for( i < end ) */
/*** ../vsm4/src/mvslib/instances/SelectionD.c ********/

Function mvsBoxBehaviorSet is defined in
mvsSetValues(Box_info, args, n) and this is where the errors happen.

The error happens in this functional call: "mvsSetValues(Box_info,

args, n);" in file ../vsm4/src/mvslib/behavior/Box.c, function
mvsBoxBehaviorSet, around line #223. Reference to report.zw030 for similar
stack sequence for functional call mvsSetValues.

This report is asking waiver for a case similar to report.zw030
which is granted.
There are 3 kinds of values for XmNresizePolicy here, in Xm.h:

enum{ XmRESIZE_NONE, XmRESIZE_GROW,
XmRESIZE_ANY
} ;

From above you can see, XmRESIZE_GROW is 1, XmRESIZE_ANY is 2 which
is default value for resource XmNresizePolicy of XmSelectionDialog widget in
this test case(in ../mvslib/instances/SelectionD.c)

I have got waiver for the following error in report.zw030:

INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=2
ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemCount: Expected 3, received 8

So here I only ask waiver for this kind of error:

INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=1
ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemCount: Expected 3, received 11

The reason here received 11 instead of 8 is because XmNresizePolicy
is different, it is XmRESIZE_GROW(1). As I explained in report.zw030,
when this XmSelectionDialog widget is created, its size is 125x125 which is
too small to display all the component of the selection dialog widget, so
the system change it to 125x378 in my machine and set the widget resource
XmNlistVisibleItemCount to be 3 according to the actually widget size, not
to be the default value 8. Later on when we call XtSetValues in "mvsSetValues"
to set any resource, the system will blowup this widget and make it more
beatiful, so that it is not narrow and long(think 125x378). When the
resource XmNresizePolicy is XmRESIZE_ANY(which is default), in my machine the
system will make the widget to be 328x325, and reset XmNlistVisibleItemCount
to be default value 8, this is what I explained in report.zw030. When the
resource XmNresizePolicy is XmRESIZE_GROW, since the height of the realized
widget is 378 and cannot be shrinked, so the system make the widget to be
328x378 in my machine, this time the widget is a little bit bigger, and it can
display 11 lines of text, so comes the value of XmNlistVisibleItemCount.

Take a look at file SelectioB.c of Xm, this file is for
XmSelectionDialog widget. In this SelectioB.c file, there is a "SetValues"
function, in the end of this function, it has:
..................................................................
if( XtClass( new_w) == xmSelectionBoxWidgetClass )
{
_XmBulletinBoardSizeUpdate( (Widget) new_w) ;
}
..................................................................

Function _XmBulletinBoardSizeUpdate is defined in Xm BulletinB.c,
in this function, it has:
..................................................................
_XmHandleSizeUpdate( (Widget) bbWid, BB_ResizePolicy( bbWid),
classPtr->bulletin_board_class.geo_matrix_create) ;
..................................................................

Function _XmHandleSizeUpdate is defined in Xm GeoUtils.c. In this
function, it calculates the bulletin board size according to different
XmNresizePolicy resource value. Take a look at this function, then it will
become very clear why XmNlistVisibleItemCount is 11 this time when the
XmNresizePolicy is XmRESIZE_GROW instead of XmRESIZE_ANY.

Test Output

TEST CASE: XmSelectionDialog

TEST PURPOSE #4
The XmSelectionDialog widget shall exhibit the behavior
defined in the Motif Toolkit API specification.
INFO: Key code collision between osfCancel and Escape
INFO: This may be a problem: Check your .motifbind file
INFO: ***************** Beginning Iteration 1 of 48 ****************
INFO: --XmNsensitive=True
INFO: --XmNallowOverlap=True
INFO: --XmNautoUnmanage=True
INFO: --XmNmustMatch=True
INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=0
TEST: ListButtonMotion
PREP: Unmap on activate of Cancel
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
TEST: Call the cancel callback if a cancel button exists

PREP: Map
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNmapCallback when map occurs
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
PREP: Unmap
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNunmapCallback when unmap occurs
PREP: Map
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNmapCallback when map occurs
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
PREP: Activate of Help
TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
PREP: Unmap on activate of Ok
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
TEST: Activate of Ok with autoUnmanage causes ok callback and unmap callback
PREP: Destroy Box Manager
TEST: Destroying the widget results in a destroy callback
INFO: ***************** Beginning Iteration 2 of 48 ****************
INFO: ***************** Beginning Iteration 17 of 48 ****************
INFO: --XmNsensitive=True
INFO: --XmNallowOverlap=True
INFO: --XmNautoUnmanage=True
INFO: --XmNmustMatch=True
INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=2
ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemCount: Expected 3, received 8
PREP: Unmap on activate of Cancel
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
TEST: Call the cancel callback if a cancel button exists

PREP: Map
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNmapCallback when map occurs
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
PREP: Unmap
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNunmapCallback when unmap occurs
PREP: Map
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNmapCallback when map occurs
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
PREP: Activate of Help
TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
PREP: Unmap on activate of Ok
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
TEST: Activate of Ok with autoUnmanage causes ok callback and unmap callback
PREP: Destroy Box Manager
TEST: Destroying the widget results in a destroy callback
INFO: ***************** Beginning Iteration 18 of 48 ****************
INFO: --XmNsensitive=False
INFO: --XmNallowOverlap=True
INFO: --XmNautoUnmanage=True
INFO: --XmNmustMatch=True
INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=2
ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemCount: Expected 3, received 8
PREP: Click KHelp over manager
PREP: Destroy Box Manager
TEST: Destroying the widget results in a destroy callback
INFO: ***************** Beginning Iteration 19 of 48 ****************
INFO: ***************** Beginning Iteration 33 of 48 ****************
INFO: --XmNsensitive=True
INFO: --XmNallowOverlap=True
INFO: --XmNautoUnmanage=True
INFO: --XmNmustMatch=True
INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=1
ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemCount: Expected 3, received 11
PREP: Unmap on activate of Cancel
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget

TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
TEST: Call the cancel callback if a cancel button exists
PREP: Map
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNmapCallback when map occurs
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
PREP: Unmap
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNunmapCallback when unmap occurs
PREP: Map
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNmapCallback when map occurs
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
PREP: Activate of Help
TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
PREP: Unmap on activate of Ok
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
TEST: Activate of Ok with autoUnmanage causes ok callback and unmap callback
PREP: Destroy Box Manager
TEST: Destroying the widget results in a destroy callback
INFO: ***************** Beginning Iteration 34 of 48 ****************
INFO: --XmNsensitive=False
INFO: --XmNallowOverlap=True
INFO: --XmNautoUnmanage=True
INFO: --XmNmustMatch=True
INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=1
ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemCount: Expected 3, received 11
PREP: Click KHelp over manager
PREP: Destroy Box Manager
TEST: Destroying the widget results in a destroy callback

INFO: ***************** Beginning Iteration 35 of 48 ****************
INFO: --XmNsensitive=True
INFO: --XmNallowOverlap=False
INFO: --XmNautoUnmanage=True
INFO: --XmNmustMatch=True
INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=1
ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemCount: Expected 3, received 11
PREP: Unmap on activate of Cancel
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
TEST: Call the cancel callback if a cancel button exists
PREP: Map
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNmapCallback when map occurs
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
PREP: Unmap
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNunmapCallback when unmap occurs
PREP: Map
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNmapCallback when map occurs
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
PREP: Activate of Help
TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
PREP: Unmap on activate of Ok
TEST: Call the callbacks for XmNfocusCallback when focus enters widget
TEST: New active region
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be armed.
TEST: Causes the current gadget to be activated.
TEST: The cancel button is the selected region
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in no match callback when Text selecti
on does not match
TEST: Activation of the Apply button results in apply callback
TEST: Activation of the Help button results in help callback
TEST: Activation of the Ok button results in ok callback
TEST: Activate of Ok with autoUnmanage causes ok callback and unmap callback
PREP: Destroy Box Manager
TEST: Destroying the widget results in a destroy callback
INFO: ***************** Beginning Iteration 36 of 48 ****************

INFO: ***************** Beginning Iteration 48 of 48 ****************
INFO: --XmNsensitive=False
INFO: --XmNallowOverlap=False
INFO: --XmNautoUnmanage=False
INFO: --XmNmustMatch=False
INFO: --XmNresizePolicy=1
ERROR: Resource XmNlistVisibleItemCount: Expected 3, received 11
PREP: Click KHelp over manager
PREP: Destroy Box Manager
TEST: Destroying the widget results in a destroy callback
4 FAIL

Review Information

Review Type TSMA Review

Start Date null

Completed null

Status Complete

Review Recommendation No Resolution Given

Review Response
The value of the XmNhistoryVisibleItemCount resource is defined to
be dynamic and should reflect adjustments to the widget size
which occur as a result of normal client windown manager intervention,
as appears to have happened in this case and the case of TSD4M.00013 and
TSD4M.00014.

We recommend that this waiver request be granted as a TSD.

Review Type SA Review

Start Date null

Completed null

Status Complete

Review Resolution Test Suite Deficiency (TSD)

Review Conclusion
This is an agreed Test Suite Deficiency.

Problem Reporting System Options:

View Report 2191

List All PRs

Search Reports

Email the System Administrator

View the The Open Brand Interpretations Database User Manual

Contact the Certification Authority