Home • About Us • A-Z Index • Search * Contact Us • Register • Login • Press • Shop

The Open Brand -- Problem Reporting and Interpretations System

Problem Report 1858 Details

Help Show help | Quick Search | Submit a Test Suite Support Request | Click here to view your privileges

This page provides all information on Problem Report 1858.

Report 1858 Actions

    Problem Report Number 1858
    Submitter's Classification Minor System Fault
    State Resolved
    Resolution Minor System Fault (MSF)
    Problem Resolution ID MSF.X.0079
    Raised 2001-09-19 08:00
    Updated 2003-03-13 08:00
    Published 2001-10-04 08:00
    Expiry Date 2002-10-03
    Product Standard Window System Application Interface V2
    Certification Program The Open Brand certification program
    Test Suite VSW version 5.1.2
    Test Identification Xlib11/GraphicsExpose 1
    Problem Summary MSF4W.00029 A temporary waiver is requested for a minor problem related to GraphicsExpose events.
    Problem Text
    Affected;
    Xlib11/GraphicsExpose-1
    XProto/CopyPlane-1
    Xlib9/XCopyPlane-5,6

    On systems with FFB framebuffers (FFB, FFB2, FFB2+, both single and
    double buffered tested), the test /tset/Xlib11/grphcexps fails with
    Unresolved.
    The CopyPlane ane XCopyPlane failures are related to this.

    The tests pass using other Framebuffers types.

    A bug was introduced into the framebuffer driver and is currently
    being resolved.
    In the meantime, we are requesting a temporary waiver for these, as
    we do not yet know when the fix would be ready integrate into
    Solaris 8, although a patch is tentatively targeted for a s8update7
    build.
    Evaluation quote: "We had recently integrated CopyPlane acceleration
    and that was the reason for the regressions in s8update6 build 6.
    The width and height values being passed to the bitblt function
    were incorrect"


    Test Output
    Failure for Xlib11/GraphicsExpose causes failures in
    XProto/CopyPlane-1
    Xlib9/XCopyPlane-5,6

    Journal results;
    10|1360 /tset/Xlib11/grphcsexps/Test 17:02:50|TC Start, scenario ref 918-0
    15|1360 3.1-lite 1|TCM Start
    400|1360 1 1 17:02:55|IC Start
    200|1360 1 17:02:55|TP Start
    520|1360 1 00017184 1 1|VSW5TESTSUITE PURPOSE 1
    520|1360 1 00017184 1 2|Assertion GraphicsExpose-1.(A)
    520|1360 1 00017184 1 3|When GraphicsExpose events are generated, then they are
    520|1360 1 00017184 1 4|contiguously delivered by the server.
    520|1360 1 00017184 1 5|METH: Create a pair of windows.
    520|1360 1 00017184 1 6|METH: Create a gc with graphics-exposures flag set to Tr
    ue.
    520|1360 1 00017184 1 7|METH: Generate GraphicsExpose events.
    520|1360 1 00017184 1 8|METH: Verify that events were generated.
    520|1360 1 00017184 1 9|METH: Verify that events were delivered contiguously.
    520|1360 1 00017184 1 10|REPORT: Received NoExpose event while only expecting Gr
    aphicsExpose types
    520|1360 1 00017184 1 11|REPORT: Unexpected event received.
    220|1360 1 2 17:02:55|UNRESOLVED

    10|70 /tset/Xproto/cpypln/Test 15:27:34|TC Start, scenario ref 49-0
    15|70 3.1-lite 3|TCM Start
    400|70 1 1 15:27:39|IC Start
    200|70 1 15:27:39|TP Start
    520|70 1 00025331 1 1|VSW5TESTSUITE PURPOSE 1
    520|70 1 00025331 1 2|Assertion CopyPlane-1.(A)
    520|70 1 00025331 1 3|When a client sends a valid CopyPlane protocol request to
    520|70 1 00025331 1 4|the X server, and graphics-exposures in the graphics conte
    xt
    520|70 1 00025331 1 5|is True, then the X server sends back a GraphicsExpose
    520|70 1 00025331 1 6|event to the client.
    520|70 1 00025331 1 7|METH: Call library function testfunc() to do the following
    :
    520|70 1 00025331 1 8|METH: Open a connection to the X server using native byte
    sex.
    520|70 1 00025331 1 9|METH: Send a valid CopyPlane protocol request to the X ser
    ver.
    520|70 1 00025331 1 10|METH: Verify that the X server sends back a GraphicsExpos
    e event.
    520|70 1 00025331 1 11|METH: Open a connection to the X server using reversed by
    te sex.
    520|70 1 00025331 1 12|METH: Send a valid CopyPlane protocol request to the X se
    rver.
    520|70 1 00025343 1 1|REPORT: Expect: wanted EVENT - GraphicsExpose , got EVENT
    - NoExpose
    520|70 1 00025343 1 2|REPORT: Expect: wanted EVENT - GraphicsExpose , got NOTHIN
    G
    520|70 1 00025343 1 3|REPORT: client 0 failed to receive GraphicsExpose
    520|70 1 00025343 1 4|REPORT: Test CopyPlane failed with 3 errors.
    520|70 1 00025344 1 1|REPORT: Expect: wanted EVENT - GraphicsExpose , got EVENT
    - NoExpose
    520|70 1 00025344 1 2|REPORT: Expect: wanted EVENT - GraphicsExpose , got NOTHIN
    G
    520|70 1 00025344 1 3|REPORT: client 0 failed to receive GraphicsExpose
    520|70 1 00025344 1 4|REPORT: Test CopyPlane failed with 3 errors.
    220|70 1 1 15:27:39|FAIL
    410|70 1 1 15:27:39|IC End

    520|1120 5 00013010 1 1|VSW5TESTSUITE PURPOSE 5
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 2|Assertion XCopyPlane-5.(A)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 3|When regions of the source rectangle are obscured and ha
    ve
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 4|not been retained in backing store or regions outside th
    e
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 5|boundaries of the source drawable are specified and the
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 6|destination is a window with a background other than Non
    e,
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 7|then all corresponding destination regions that are eith
    er
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 8|visible or are retained in backing store are tiled with
    that
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 9|background with plane-mask of all ones and GXcopy functi
    on.
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 10|METH: make src window and draw into it (background of 0
    )
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 11|METH: make dest window with background of 1 and draw in
    to it
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 12|METH: copy region that extends off the edge of the sour
    ce drawable
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 13|METH: verify that it is not copied.
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 14|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 15|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 16|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 17|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 18|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 19|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 20|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 21|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 22|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 23|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 24|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 25|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 26|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 27|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 28|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 29|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 30|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 31|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 32|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 33|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 34|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 35|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 36|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 37|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 38|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 39|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 40|REPORT: Bad pixel in tiled area at (1, 0)
    520|1120 5 00013010 1 41|REPORT: area was not copied properly
    220|1120 5 1 16:32:45|FAIL
    410|1120 5 1 16:32:45|IC End
    400|1120 6 1 16:32:45|IC Start
    200|1120 6 16:32:45|TP Start
    520|1120 6 00013010 1 1|VSW5TESTSUITE PURPOSE 6
    520|1120 6 00013010 1 2|Assertion XCopyPlane-6.(A)
    520|1120 6 00013010 1 3|When graphics-exposures is True, then GraphicsExpose
    520|1120 6 00013010 1 4|events for all corresponding destination regions are
    520|1120 6 00013010 1 5|generated.
    520|1120 6 00013010 1 6|METH: Set graphics-exposures to True.
    520|1120 6 00013010 1 7|METH: Enable All Events.
    520|1120 6 00013010 1 8|METH: DO as above.
    520|1120 6 00013010 1 9|METH: Check events received, and x,y,width,height in eac
    h.
    520|1120 6 00013010 1 10|REPORT: Expecting one GraphicsExpose event
    220|1120 6 1 16:32:45|FAIL

    Xlib9/XCopyPlane-5,6 ;

    Review Information

    Review Type TSMA Review
    Start Date null
    Completed null
    Status Complete
    Review Recommendation No Resolution Given
    Review Response
    This fault is not expected to have an adverse effect on application
    portability. It will only affect end users, who may see incorrect
    screen contents under certain circumstances. Whilst the end user
    may not see this as a minor problem, it can be considered to be
    more a quality-of-implementation issue than a standards compliance
    issue. A temporary waiver is recommended.

    Review Type SA Review
    Start Date null
    Completed null
    Status Complete
    Review Resolution Minor System Fault (MSF)
    Review Conclusion
    A Temporary Waiver is granted.

    Problem Reporting System Options:

     

    Back   

Contact the Certification Authority