Home • About Us • A-Z Index • Search * Contact Us • Register • Login • Press • Shop

The Open Brand -- Problem Reporting and Interpretations System

Problem Report 1789 Details

Help Show help | Quick Search | Submit a Test Suite Support Request | Click here to view your privileges

This page provides all information on Problem Report 1789.

Report 1789 Actions

    Problem Report Number 1789
    Submitter's Classification Test Suite problem
    State Resolved
    Resolution Test Suite Deficiency (TSD)
    Problem Resolution ID TSD.X.0866
    Raised 1970-01-01 08:00
    Updated 2003-03-13 08:00
    Published 1999-01-28 08:00
    Product Standard X Window System Applications Interface
    Certification Program The Open Brand certification program
    Test Suite VSW version 5.0.1
    Test Identification Xt6/VendorShellWidget-10 10
    Problem Summary TSD4W.00160 This test may fail on implementations using X11R6 Athena widgt implementations.
    Problem Text
    In examining the Xt6 tests
    VendorShellWidget-10, TransientShellWidget-10,TopLevelSHellWidget-10, and
    ApplicationShellWidget-10.

    Our failures appear to be similar to the waiver TSD4W.00140
    That waiver only claims that for the implementation supplied Athena
    Widget set overrides wm_hints.input.

    We're also getting errors for core.detroy_callbacks,
    composite.children, composite.num_children, and composite.num_slots.

    Our implementation of the Athena Widget set (for R6) overrides the
    defaults whereas the implementation in R5 did not.

    In x/xc/lib/Xaw/XawIm.c in the function _XawImInitialize it makes a
    call to XtAddCallback (w, XtNdestroyCallback, ...) which was added
    for R6 and in /x/xc/lib/Xaw/Vendor.c in the function
    XawVendorShellInitialize it makes a call to
    XtCreateWidget("shellext", xawvendorShellExtWidgetClass,
    Test Output
    15|0 3.2-lite 1|TCM Start

    400|0 10 1 17:27:56|IC Start

    200|0 10 17:27:56|TP Start

    520|0 10 00043165 1 1|VSW5TESTSUITE PURPOSE 10

    520|0 10 00043165 1 2|Assertion VendorShellWidget-10.(A)

    520|0 10 00043165 1 3|VendorShellRec shall be initialized to the default values

    520|0 10 00043165 1 4|specified in sections 3.4.1, 3.4.2 and 6.1.4 of the

    520|0 10 00043165 1 5|Specification on creation of a new shell widget instance.

    520|0 10 00034975 1 1|PREP: Initialize toolkit, Open display and Create topLevel root widget

    520|0 10 00034975 1 2|PREP: Create fresh widget

    520|0 10 00034975 1 3|TEST: core.self

    520|0 10 00034975 1 4|TEST: core.widget_class

    520|0 10 00034975 1 5|TEST: core.parent

    520|0 10 00034975 1 6|TEST: core.being_destroyed

    520|0 10 00034975 1 7|TEST: core.destroy_callbacks

    520|0 10 00034975 1 8|ERROR: destroy_callbacks member is not NULL

    520|0 10 00034975 1 9|TEST: core.constraints

    520|0 10 00034975 1 10|TEST: core.x

    520|0 10 00034975 1 11|TEST: core.y

    520|0 10 00034975 1 12|TEST: core.width

    520|0 10 00034975 1 13|TEST: core.height

    520|0 10 00034975 1 14|TEST: core.border_width

    520|0 10 00034975 1 15|TEST: core.managed

    520|0 10 00034975 1 16|TEST: core.sensitive

    520|0 10 00034975 1 17|TEST: core.ancestor_sensitive

    520|0 10 00034975 1 18|TEST: core.accelerators

    520|0 10 00034975 1 19|TEST: core.border_pixel

    520|0 10 00034975 1 20|TEST: core.border_pixmap

    520|0 10 00034975 1 21|TEST: core.popup_list

    520|0 10 00034975 1 22|TEST: core.num_popups

    520|0 10 00034975 1 23|TEST: core.screen

    520|0 10 00034975 1 24|TEST: core.name

    520|0 10 00034975 1 25|TEST: core.colormap

    520|0 10 00034975 1 26|TEST: core.window

    520|0 10 00034975 1 27|TEST: core.depth

    520|0 10 00034975 1 28|TEST: core.background_pixel

    520|0 10 00034975 1 29|TEST: core.background_pixmap

    520|0 10 00034975 1 30|TEST: core.visible

    520|0 10 00034975 1 31|TEST: core.mapped_when_managed

    520|0 10 00034975 1 32|TEST: composite.children

    520|0 10 00034975 1 33|ERROR: children member is not NULL

    520|0 10 00034975 1 34|TEST: composite.num_children

    520|0 10 00034975 1 35|ERROR: num_children member is 1, expected 0

    520|0 10 00034975 1 36|TEST: composite.num_slots

    520|0 10 00034975 1 37|ERROR: num_slots member is 2, expected 0

    520|0 10 00034975 1 38|TEST: shell.geometry

    520|0 10 00034975 1 39|TEST: shell.create_popup_child_proc

    520|0 10 00034975 1 40|TEST: shell.popped_up

    520|0 10 00034975 1 41|TEST: shell.allow_shell_resize

    520|0 10 00034975 1 42|TEST: shell.save_under

    520|0 10 00034975 1 43|TEST: shell.override_redirect

    520|0 10 00034975 1 44|TEST: shell.popup_callback

    520|0 10 00034975 1 45|TEST: shell.popdown_callback

    520|0 10 00034975 1 46|TEST: wm.title

    520|0 10 00034975 1 47|TEST: wm.wm_timeout

    520|0 10 00034975 1 48|TEST: wm.wait_for_wm

    520|0 10 00034975 1 49|TEST: wm.transient

    520|0 10 00034975 1 50|TEST: wm.size_hints.min_width

    520|0 10 00034975 1 51|TEST: wm.size_hints.min_height

    520|0 10 00034975 1 52|TEST: wm.size_hints.max_width

    520|0 10 00034975 1 53|TEST: wm.size_hints.max_height

    520|0 10 00034975 1 54|TEST: wm.size_hints.width_inc

    520|0 10 00034975 1 55|TEST: wm.size_hints.height_inc

    520|0 10 00034975 1 56|TEST: wm.size_hints.min_aspect.x

    520|0 10 00034975 1 57|TEST: wm.size_hints.min_aspect.y

    520|0 10 00034975 1 58|TEST: wm.size_hints.max_aspect.x

    520|0 10 00034975 1 59|TEST: wm.size_hints.max_aspect.y

    520|0 10 00034975 1 60|TEST: wm.wm_hints.input

    520|0 10 00034975 1 61|TEST: wm.wm_hints.icon_x

    520|0 10 00034975 1 62|TEST: wm.wm_hints.icon_y

    520|0 10 00034975 1 63|TEST: wm.wm_hints.window_group

    520|0 10 00034975 1 64|TEST: wm.base_width

    520|0 10 00034975 1 65|TEST: wm.base_height

    520|0 10 00034975 1 66|TEST: wm.win_gravity

    520|0 10 00034975 1 67|TEST: wm.title_encoding

    220|0 10 1 17:27:57|FAIL

    410|0 10 1 17:27:57|IC End

    Review Information

    Review Type TSMA Review
    Start Date null
    Completed null
    Status Complete
    Review Recommendation No Resolution Given
    Review Response
    We agree this is a test suite deficiency in the test
    suite version(s) listed.

    The test may also include following ERROR: line

    TEST: wm.wm_hints.input
    ERROR: wm_hints.input member is 1, expected False
    TEST: wm.wm_hints.icon_x

    which is also valid.

    Review Type SA Review
    Start Date null
    Completed null
    Status Complete
    Review Resolution Test Suite Deficiency (TSD)
    Review Conclusion
    This is an agreed Test Suite Deficiency.

    Problem Reporting System Options:

     

    Back   

Contact the Certification Authority